By: Glenn Harbison / glenn@fanninbasin.com
Sides for and against an application for both Conditional Use and a Special Exemption Variance that would allow a hotel to be built in Blue Ridge made their appeals to the Blue Ridge City Council Tuesday, June 16.
In the end, council members approved both measures by a 3-2 vote, clearing the way for construction at the intersection of East Main and Mountain streets. The council’s decision agreed with the recommendations of both the city’s staff and planning commission.
Troy Shirbroun, president of the Blue Ridge Business Association, voiced that group’s support for the project.
Shirbroun said that while Blue Ridge is extraordinary at attracting visitors, most of them drive in, walk around for a few hours, and leave. “A hotel guest is different,” he said, describing them as checking in then walking everywhere during their stay. He said this would serve to decrease downtown traffic while providing an economic boost to Blue Ridge merchants.
He also cautioned, “If not a hotel – what?” Because the land is zoned Central Business District (CBD), several businesses that could actually prove harmful to the mom and pop businesses downtown, such as a big box retail strip, a chain restaurant or a fast food operation, would not have to get permission from the city. CBD rules would allow many to move right in.
He also called for the specific conditions the city has placed on the developers to be written and enforced. He assured the council the business association “supports thoughtful development.”
The project’s developer, Steve Bell, told the council he believes the hotel is “a product we’re proud to present.”
Former city council member Angie Arp spoke in opposition to the project. She said a hotel would create a negative impact on traffic, pedestrian traffic and community character, pointing to the daily impact it would have on residents.
She said council approval would be “setting a precedence” because variances and conditional uses are supposed to be granted only when there is a “clear and compelling reason,” which she believes does not exist for the hotel.
Richard Arnold, who also opposed the hotel, said granting the requests would “open up a flood gate.” He said residents of the city “do not want it” and it does not fit the purpose of the Central Business District.
During council discussion, Councilman Jack Taylor called the site involved “a perfect location” for a hotel.
Councilwoman Christy Kay said the request presented “a hard decision” for her, one she had studied closely, talked to several individuals about, and did not take lightly.
Councilman Bubba Gibbs said he felt a hotel would be “the least impactful” development at the site.
Taylor, Kay and Gibbs all voted in favor of the conditional use and special variance, while Bill Bivins and Jacqueline Kiker opposed.
The decision makes room for an 80 room hotel expected to employ 19 people.






Leave a Reply